Reignite Your Impact: Make a Difference Again
This campaign focuses on re-engaging lapsed donors by reminding them of their past contributions' transformative impact and inviting them to renew their support with personalized outreach.
.webp)
Get The Giving Circle Playbook
Overview
This campaign is designed to reconnect with lapsed donors by sharing stories of the organization’s achievements and future plans while emphasizing the importance of their renewed support. Through tailored messaging and personalized outreach, donors are reminded of their past impact and motivated to give again. The campaign capitalizes on a donor’s existing familiarity with the nonprofit and uses transparency and storytelling to re-establish trust and commitment.
Why this works: Reaching out to lapsed donors leverages a pre-existing connection to the nonprofit’s mission. Sharing personalized updates on how their previous contributions created real change, combined with clear calls-to-action, increases the likelihood of rekindling their support. When framed as an opportunity to make a difference again, lapsed donors often feel inspired to re-engage.
Key Tactics:
- Personalized Outreach: Tailor messages to highlight donors’ past involvement and the continued need for their support.
- Storytelling: Showcase success stories that demonstrate the impact of past contributions and align with future goals.
- Incentives: Promote limited-time donation matches or special recognitions to create urgency.
- Impact Reporting: Provide transparency about how renewed support will create meaningful change.
Channels:
- Email Marketing
- Social Media
- Direct Mail (for high-value donors)
- Paid Ads (Google Ads, Facebook/Instagram Ads)
- Website and Landing Pages
Primary Goal
Re-engage lapsed donors and secure contributions from 20% of the targeted group.
Objectives
- Reconnect with 50% of lapsed donors through email and social media engagement.
- Convert 20% of lapsed donors into contributors, with a focus on one-time and recurring gifts.
- Increase social media engagement by 25% through storytelling and success updates.
Key Campaign Metrics
- Donor Re-Engagement Rate: Percentage of lapsed donors engaging with email or social media.
- Donation Conversion Rate: Percentage of lapsed donors contributing during the campaign.
- Average Donation Size: Measure the average gift size to assess campaign effectiveness.
- Email Performance: Track open and click-through rates for personalized messages.
- Social Media Metrics: Monitor likes, shares, comments, and impressions to gauge outreach success.
Donor Segments
- Lapsed Donors: Donors who haven’t contributed in 12+ months.
- Loyal Donors: Long-time supporters who missed a year of giving.
- Recurring Donors: Donors who previously gave monthly but have paused their contributions.
- High-Value Lapsed Donors: Major past donors who may be re-engaged with personalized outreach.
Donor Engagement Journey
Awareness Stage
Reconnect with lapsed donors by reminding them of their past contributions through targeted messaging. Use social media posts with real-life testimonials, email outreach highlighting their past impact, and visual content that introduces the campaign's goals.
Consideration Stage
Motivate donors to act by offering impact reports, success stories, and updates that emotionally connect them to the cause. Use personalized outreach, such as calls or video messages from key staff or board members, to engage high-value donors. Highlight how their renewed support can fuel specific initiatives.
Decision Stage
Drive donations with clear CTAs emphasizing urgency, such as “Help us reach our year-end goal by making a gift today!” Use limited-time incentives, like donation matches, to create excitement. Incorporate progress trackers and live updates to show how close the organization is to meeting its goals.
Post-Donation Engagement
Strengthen relationships with automated thank-you emails, including impact updates on how their renewed contribution will be used. Follow up with a personalized acknowledgment for high-value donors and offer opportunities to transition into recurring giving.
Email Marketing
Email serves as a direct and personalized way to re-engage lapsed donors.
- Key Assets: Develop personalized email templates with donor-specific details, such as past contributions and their impact. Include compelling stories and bold CTAs, like “Reignite Your Impact Today.” Use automated follow-ups to share results and encourage recurring giving.
Direct Mail Strategy
For high-value lapsed donors, send a personalized letter thanking them for their past support, sharing the nonprofit’s current achievements, and inviting them to give again.
- Key Assets: Send customized letters on branded stationery with impact brochures highlighting accomplishments. Include a tear-off donation slip for convenience.
Social Media
Social platforms expand campaign reach and engage donors with visual storytelling.
- Key Assets: Share video testimonials from beneficiaries and infographics showcasing progress since the donor’s last contribution. Use live updates with real-time progress bars and engaging CTAs to drive action.
Website & Landing Pages
The website serves as the campaign hub, centralizing all donor engagement.
- Key Assets: Create a dynamic landing page with tailored messaging, an embedded progress tracker, and a mobile-friendly donation form. Offer downloadable impact reports to reinforce trust and transparency.
Paid Ads
Paid ads extend the campaign’s reach to donors who may not engage via email or direct mail.
- Key Assets: Use retargeting ads to re-engage donors who visited the campaign page but didn’t donate. Share short, emotional video ads emphasizing urgency and showcasing donor impact.
By following these key requirements, your Reignite Your Impact campaign will be equipped for success, with every piece in place to re-engage lapsed donors and drive new contributions. For more details, templates, and content examples, download the complete campaign guide PDF.
Campaign Requirements:
Donately Account
- Why It's Important: Donately facilitates donation tracking, real-time progress updates, and automated thank-you emails, ensuring a seamless donor experience. It also provides tools for creating personalized donation forms tailored to lapsed donors.
Email Marketing Platform
- Why It's Important: Platforms like Mailchimp or Constant Contact enable segmentation of lapsed donors and automation of personalized email sequences, ensuring effective and timely outreach.
Donor Segmentation List
- Why It's Important: Segmentation ensures targeted messaging. Organizing donors by type (e.g., loyal, high-value, recurring) allows communications to be tailored to their specific giving history.
Campaign Landing Page
- Why It's Important: A centralized page consolidates messaging and provides an easy path for donors to renew their support. The page should include impact stories, a progress tracker, and an accessible donation form.
Customized Donation Form
- Why It's Important: Tailored forms simplify the donation process and emphasize options like one-click recurring giving, increasing conversion rates.
Storytelling and Impact Content
- Why It's Important: Sharing stories of past achievements fosters emotional connection and motivates renewed support. Highlight how future donations will continue to drive meaningful impact.
Internal Team Coordination
- Why It's Important: Cross-team alignment ensures consistent messaging across all channels, effective donor targeting, and smooth execution of personalized outreach.
Tracking and Analytics
- Why It's Important: Use tools like Google Analytics and Donately’s reporting features to monitor email performance, donor engagement, and overall campaign success.
Steps to Launch and Track Your Campaign
To launch this campaign, follow these simple steps to plan, launch, and track the campaign progress.
Final Push & Countdown
As the campaign nears its end, encourage board members to make a final push with their networks by sharing urgent CTAs, using countdown graphics, and re-emphasizing the importance of every donation. Send a reminder email to fundraisers with tips on how to engage last-minute donors.
Tips to Succeed
Use Data and Analytics to Refine Strategy
Create a Strong Call-to-Action
Offer Tiered Donation Levels
Highlight Impact
Join thousands using Donately to manage fundraising.
.webp)
